MSP vs. Consulting Services

Why One Size Doesn’t Fit All in Contingent Workforce Management

Or, why “just outsource it” is not the adult version of problem-solving we were promised.

Let’s get real: large companies today rely on the contingent workforce like toddlers rely on snacks—constantly, desperately, and with little memory of what came before. From hourly contractors to high-end consultants, non-employee labor has become essential to getting real work done. But while usage has exploded, thoughtful non-employee management hasn’t caught up.

Here’s the irony: companies pour millions into extended workforce strategies, only to realize later that no one knows exactly who’s doing what, how much it costs, or who approved that random invoice from "Dave, the contractor, probably?"

Enter stage left: the Vendor Management System (VMS). It’s shiny, it has dashboards, and it promises to bring order to chaos. And yet, buying a VMS without a plan is like buying a treadmill and expecting it to run for you.

So what’s the solution? Outsource it all? Hire internally? Consult a psychic? (Tempting.)

It comes down to choosing the right approach—and knowing that when managing your contingent workforce, one size does not fit all.

MSP: Managed Service Provider or Massive Set of Problems?

The MSP model has long been the default choice for companies that want someone else to handle their non-employee labor, and don’t mind paying (or not always knowing) what’s happening under the hood.

Imagine putting your extended workforce into the hands of a third party and saying, “You’ve got this, right?” It can work beautifully. But spectacularly, it can backfire if you don’t understand the trade-offs.

What’s Great About MSPs:

• All-In-One Management: This is like the all-inclusive resort of workforce strategies—if you want minimal touch, this is it.

• Cost Sharing: Vendor-funded programs mean less upfront cost. It's like someone else buying dinner with your credit card points.

• Scalability: You can scale up or down faster than saying, “We’re behind schedule.”

• Standardization: Everything has a process. A form. A workflow. It’s heaven for Type-A personalities.

• Reporting Tools: Sophisticated analytics with charts that scream, “Look how strategic we are!”

• Compliance Buffer: The legal gray zone suddenly has more light.

  
  

When the MSP Glow Wears Off:

• Loss of Control: You’re no longer the captain—you’re more like a backseat driver with your hands zip-tied.

• Internal Confusion: Your employees wonder if they’ve been outsourced emotionally.

• Vendor Dependency: If the MSP fails, so does your entire contingent workforce operation.

• Supplier Drama: When suppliers fund the program, you might get more sales pitches than strategy.

• Data & Relationship Ownership: You may need to file a FOIA request just to access your supplier list.

• 
  

Consulting Services: Like an MSP, But With Boundaries and Better Snacks

Imagine working with a strategic advisor who listens, builds something around your needs, and then hands you the keys to drive it. That’s what contingent workforce consulting looks like.

You get expertise, minus the outsourcing hangover. It’s like hiring Gordon Ramsay to help you meal prep instead of moving into your kitchen full-time and yelling at your toaster.

When Consulting Makes More Sense:

• You want to optimize without surrendering your soul.

• Your non-employee labor spend isn’t enough to justify full MSP bells and whistles.

• You’ve got solid internal people, but they need a roadmap.

• You’re managing risk like a tightrope walker without a net and want some backup.

• You want control, visibility, and a partner who isn’t trying to upsell you during every check-in.

  
  

Real-Life Consulting Projects That Move the Needle

At Tracz Consulting, we help companies across industries navigate the messy middle between “we have no idea what we’re doing” and “we’re ready to present at SIA.”

VMS Implementation & Optimization

You bought a VMS—congratulations! Now what? We help you configure it so it actually supports your program, not just collects dust and dashboards.

Supplier Rationalization

You have 63 suppliers. Only 7 are adding value. The others are basically pen pals. We’ll help you clean house and negotiate smarter.

Rate Card Strategy

Are you paying market rates? Or did your supplier pull a number out of a hat with glitter on it? We’ll analyze your data, benchmark the market, and help you pay fairly—but wisely.

Compliance Audits & IC Classification

If you’re sweating over contractor risk, you’re not alone. We help organizations create policies and processes that withstand scrutiny (and audits).

Direct Sourcing Strategy

We’ll help you stop saying, “We need to build a talent pool,” and do it.

Cost Optimization & Workforce Analytics

What’s working? What’s not? Where is your program quietly hemorrhaging money? We’ll surface it and fix it.

Change Management

We don’t just make the plan—we help you socialize it, roll it out, and get buy-in from the people who matter.

Why Tracz Consulting?

Because you don’t need another cookie-cutter plan from a firm that just discovered what a contractor is. You need a contingent workforce consulting partner who’s been in the trenches and likes solving these problems.

Tracz Consulting is a strategic advisor to companies navigating complex non-employee management challenges. We build programs around your goals—not ours. There are no vendor agendas, and there is no “let’s just implement what worked for that other client last year” mentality.

We help you:

✅ Build more innovative programs

✅ Avoid common compliance pitfalls

✅ Gain visibility into spend and supplier performance

✅ enjoy the process (okay, maybe that’s just us, but still)

The Bottom Line

Whether you go full MSP or bring in consulting support, the goal is to optimize your contingent workforce strategy for better results, less chaos, and fewer awkward supplier calls.

You don’t need a vendor who takes over. You need a partner who lifts you. (Like a strategic Mary Poppins—minus the singing.)

Ready to stop making guesses and start making moves? Let’s discuss building a non-employee labor strategy that fits your business and budget.

Contact Tracz Consulting for a consultation. We'll tell you what you need to hear, not just what sounds good in a pitch deck.